Buying

We want your stuff! Don’t make us mug you on the street for it, like that one time.

Bring us your old comics, toys, and collectible cards, and if we’re interested, we’ll give you a fair price for them. Keep in mind that not every treasure is worth a lot of money, especially if it’s been damaged by time and (mis)use; we’ll always be honest with you about what your things are worth!

If possible, please call ahead and make an appointment. We’re unavailable for buying on Tuesdays; Mondays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays are always best.

If you have Magic: The Gathering cards and collections to part with, we’d be happy to take a look! We buy for cash or store credit.* Remember that damage and wear may devalue your card(s) slightly, and not every card is spectacularly valuable. Serra Angels and Shivan Dragons used to be awesome, but now we’re looking for Jace, The Mind Sculptors, Tarmogoyfs and such!

*Minors cannot be paid in cash without a parent or guardian present.

Our Wishlist

  • comics
  • used trade paperbacks, graphic novels
  • Magic: The Gathering cards
  • Pokemon cards
  • Transformers
  • Star Wars toys
  • Godzilla
  • promos
  • exclusives and variants
  • vintage professional wrestling goods
  • Kinnikuman/MUSCLE collectibles
  • medical tools
  • taxidermy
  • antiques, particularly uranium or vaseline glass
  • ICP merchandise

Appraisal

Want to know what it’s worth but not ready to part with it? We also offer an appraisal service!

At the rate of $35/hr., we’ll inventory your collection piece by piece, assign a collector’s grade to it, and tell you the sum value of the whole.

This service can be particularly useful if you’re trying to value a collection for insurance purposes!

Contact us to schedule an appointment.